fbpx

Tackling weeds integrally, these are the options

10-08-2023 | |
Dutch growers visiting a demo with machines for weed control. - Photo's: Hans Banus
Dutch growers visiting a demo with machines for weed control. - Photo's: Hans Banus

Keeping crops free of weeds without the use of herbicides is becoming increasingly difficult. The Research and innovation project of Dutch sugar beet processor Cosun shows growers what options there are for keeping weeds under mechanical control.

Weed control will require a more integrated approach in the future. In other words, a combination of chemistry with mechanical weed control. In sugar beet, it is still possible to keep the crop weed-free with the current package of chemical resources. However, the available package of resources is becoming meager and the effectiveness of resources is declining. In addition, there is the social desire to reduce the environmental impact, possibly with stricter rules for the use of herbicides in the future.

Text continues below picture

The Spike Rotoweeder from Agri Bio-Solutions is a rotating weeder. The concept comes from North America where it is mainly used in grain. The machine consists of a row of wheels with shovels attached to them. For weeds, the machine works as long as the weeds are smaller than the crop. The weeder works full-field, so the crop must be firmer than the weeds to prevent damage to the crop. The aggressiveness of the Rotoweeder depends on the driving speed and the depth, support wheels are available for loose soil. According to the importer, the machine is also very suitable for breaking crusts. In small beets, the driving speed must be limited to about 3 kilometers per hour, while larger beets can handle 6 to 7 kilometers per hour. In grain, the Rotoweeder can be driven at up to 20 kilometers per hour.
The Spike Rotoweeder from Agri Bio-Solutions is a rotating weeder. The concept comes from North America where it is mainly used in grain. The machine consists of a row of wheels with shovels attached to them. For weeds, the machine works as long as the weeds are smaller than the crop. The weeder works full-field, so the crop must be firmer than the weeds to prevent damage to the crop. The aggressiveness of the Rotoweeder depends on the driving speed and the depth, support wheels are available for loose soil. According to the importer, the machine is also very suitable for breaking crusts. In small beets, the driving speed must be limited to about 3 kilometers per hour, while larger beets can handle 6 to 7 kilometers per hour. In grain, the Rotoweeder can be driven at up to 20 kilometers per hour.

Methods of mechanical weed control

Growth power Cosun wants to accelerate integrated weed control through several projects. The focus is mainly on different methods of mechanical weed control in sugar beet and chicory. Growth power Cosun therefore constructed four so-called Weed Platforms this season in The Netherlands on the northern sand, southeastern sand, the central clay area and the southwestern clay. Machine manufacturers and suppliers are expressly invited to demonstrate new and proven techniques on the platforms. Practical tests are being carried out on the platforms to see how far the use of herbicides can be reduced.

Dutch growers are hesitant about the investment

The digital platform Unitip through which the Dutch sugar beet processor Cosun shares analyses from collective data with its growers shows that mechanical weed control has been carried out on only 5 to 7% of the beet plots in recent years. In 90% of the cases it concerns a hoeing operation. Growers are hesitant about the investment in machines, but especially about the extra time that mechanical weed control requires. With a 36-metre-wide sprayer you can get around faster than with a 6-metre-wide hoe.

Text continues below picture

The EcoRobotics Ara spot sprayer recognizes crops and weeds and can spray them with precision. At the demo in Nieuw-Balinge, the machine was used for potato storage in chicory. Using algorithms, Artificial Intelligence and camera technology, the machine recognizes the chicory plants and creates a 'safety zone' around them in which spraying is not allowed. This spot sprayer can also be used in other crops, such as sugar beet and onions. In the demo, only potato seedlings is sprayed, but the machine can be programmed to include all weeds. There is also the option of only spraying the crop, for example sugar beet against aphids, which saves enormous amounts of resources. The nozzles each spray an area of 6 x 6 centimetres, for which the machine corrects itself for height differences such as a sowing track or a sowing ridge. The 6 meter wide machine has a capacity of approximately 3 hectares per hour.
The EcoRobotics Ara spot sprayer recognizes crops and weeds and can spray them with precision. At the demo in Nieuw-Balinge, the machine was used for volunteer potatoes in chicory. Using algorithms, Artificial Intelligence and camera technology, the machine recognizes the chicory plants and creates a 'safety zone' around them in which spraying is not allowed. This spot sprayer can also be used in other crops, such as sugar beet and onions. In the demo, only potato seedlings is sprayed, but the machine can be programmed to include all weeds. There is also the option of only spraying the crop, for example sugar beet against aphids, which saves enormous amounts of resources. The nozzles each spray an area of 6 x 6 centimetres, for which the machine corrects itself for height differences such as a sowing track or a sowing ridge. The 6 meter wide machine has a capacity of approximately 3 hectares per hour.

Mechanical, in combination with less chemical

On various days in June, Dutch growers could see machines such as weeding harrows, rotating weeding harrows, camera-controlled hoes and spot sprayers at work on the Weed Platforms, and specialists explained the operation and possibilities of these machines.

The first platforms have already been installed for the third year. According to researcher Sjef van der Heijden, the experiences gained there show that a lot is possible mechanically, in combination with less chemical. For safe and effective weed control it is important to have chemicals available for the period shortly after the emergence of the crop and when in a critical period nothing can be done mechanically due to weather conditions.

Text continues below picture

The Einböck Aerostar-Rotation is a weeder with rotating tines. The star wheels are in a fixed angle, the pressure on the ground can be adjusted hydraulically. The machine is also suitable as a crust breaker and can be used in several crops. The machine was not demonstrated on the weed platform in Nieuw-Balinge because the soil was too cloddy for this machine. The clods got stuck in the star wheels.
The Einböck Aerostar-Rotation is a weeder with rotating tines. The star wheels are in a fixed angle, the pressure on the ground can be adjusted hydraulically. The machine is also suitable as a crust breaker and can be used in several crops. The machine was not demonstrated on the weed platform in Nieuw-Balinge because the soil was too cloddy for this machine. The clods got stuck in the star wheels. According to importer Reesink, the advantage of this machine compared to the 'regular' weeding harrow is that the risk of filling up with crop residues is smaller, because the rotating tines roll over it. The loosened weeds also move more, so that the soil is shaken off better. The rotary weeding harrow can work more aggressively than a 'regular' weeding harrow and is therefore better suited for a somewhat larger crop and larger weeds.

Flat and firm seed bed

Researcher Van der Heijden advocates an integrated approach in which a grower makes a plan about how he is going to tackle weed control during the season. Successful weed control starts with creating a seed bed. For mechanics, a flat and firm seedbed and even emergence is important to be able to adjust the weeding harrows and hoes properly. As an example, the researcher mentions that when sowing on loose sandy soil, a channel quickly forms where the sowing element runs. When weeding for the first time, there is a good chance that the leveling effect of this machine will cause the seed to lie very deep or that small plants will be buried under the sand.

The basis for mechanical weed control are the weeding dough and the hoeing machine. At the beginning of the season, small weeds can be tackled row-independently with the weeder. In a larger crop, the hoe in combination with finger weeders can take over. The combination complements each other nicely.

Text continues below picture

The rotary weeding harrow can work more aggressively than a 'regular' weeding harrow and is therefore better suited for a somewhat larger crop and larger weeds.
The Garford 'between row hoe' is one of the camera-controlled hoeing machines on the market. Importer Homburg claims that this machine can hoe very accurately, up to 8 millimeters from the plants. The camera that controls the hoeing bar can recognize the crop rows at an early stage, so that weeding can already take place in a small crop. The machine runs on its own wheels with discs for lateral stability. So the side-shift to correct the machine does not pull the trigger. Garford uses L or angle hoes that allow you to hoe close to the plant. These hoes also ensure that the loosely hoeed weeds do not end up between the plants. The machine is equipped with a section control that works on GPS, which is useful on sloping plots. The machine on the demo was equipped with an optical crop sensor. This measures chlorophyll or leaf mass. The grower can thus monitor crop growth and use this data for any additional fertilizer application.

Apply the right remedy at the right time

Van der Heijden emphasizes that when choosing which machine to use when, just like for chemical agents, the right agent must be applied at the right time for the best result. It is important that growers can act quickly and are willing and able to invest in time to make mechanical weed control a success.

The researcher also sees creating a false seedbed for sugar beets as a good way to mechanically tackle the first wave of weeds. When the beets have been sown deep enough, a few days after sowing, ‘blind’ harrowing can be done to hit the first germinating weeds. Adjusting a weeding harrow is a learning process for a grower. Particularly on variegated fields it is difficult to find the right compromise between damage to the crop and the number of weeds that remain.

Text continues below picture

It is still too early in the season for a weed tractor to be able to demonstrate. The Klunder weed tractor has two beams with hydraulically driven counter-rotating wheels. They pull out weeds that protrude above the crop. This is a correction machine for when weeds have been left over during regular weed control. To prevent seed formation and problems during harvesting and processing, it is important to remove these weeds and bolters. One point is that the soil should not be too hard for the weeds to be pulled out by the roots. As standard, the machine is equipped with tires with a tractor tire profile. That turned out not always to have sufficient grip on the weeds. That is why we experimented with tires with a lawn profile. It turned out to have more grip in a dry crop, but less so in a wet crop.
It is still too early in the season for a weed tractor to be able to demonstrate. The Klunder weed tractor has two beams with hydraulically driven counter-rotating wheels. They pull out weeds that protrude above the crop. This is a correction machine for when weeds have been left over during regular weed control. To prevent seed formation and problems during harvesting and processing, it is important to remove these weeds and bolters. One point is that the soil should not be too hard for the weeds to be pulled out by the roots. As standard, the machine is equipped with tires with a tractor tire profile. That turned out not always to have sufficient grip on the weeds. That is why we experimented with tires with a lawn profile. It turned out to have more grip in a dry crop, but less so in a wet crop.

Full-field spraying in combination with hoeing

Reseacher Van der Heijden also sees opportunities in so-called full-field row spraying in combination with hoeing. This is being researched in Denmark. The idea is to have the nozzles spray only a narrow strip above the row of beets using a standard wide spray boom with a nozzle distance of 25 centimetres. This can save a lot of resources while retaining capacity. The condition is that the sowing of the beets took place with GPS and that the spray boom can be corrected with GPS. A challenge is to keep the boom at exactly the right height. This option was not yet available on the Growth Power Cosun Weed Platforms.

Meijering
Luuk Meijering Arable writer
More about